The answer depends on the “disposition” of the soil—whether it is sweet (alkaline) or sour (acidic) in nature! Because the carbonates in wood ash raise soil pH, they might push neutral soil over the line into an overly alkaline condition that will harm most plants. However, if your soil is too acidic and lime has been recommended to amend it, you can opt for faster-assimilating fire pit wood ash in garden beds instead. Or you can dispose of the detritus from your ash vacuum after cleaning the fireplace.
RELATED: We Tested the Best Ash Vacuums, These Are Our Favorites for Keeping Your Fireplace Clean
I’ve found that wood ash can be a game-changer for acidic soils, especially in my own garden where the soil tested at a pH of 5.8 last spring. A local extension service recommended lime, but I opted for wood ash from my oak firewood, which worked faster and was free! Just be cautious—too much ash can tip the scales toward alkalinity, which isn’t great for most plants. A soil test kit is your best friend here; I picked one up for about $15, and it saved me from guessing. Studies from land-grant universities suggest that wood ash can raise pH by 0.5 to 1.0 units per application, depending on soil type, so start small and retest after a few months.
6 Benefits of Using Wood Ash in Garden Beds
Before applying any “ash fertilizer” to soil or ash in compost, have your soil tested to determine its current pH level. Michigan State University warns that “when wood ash is used at pH levels above 6.5, interference with plant growth may occur as the alkalinity level of the soil increases.” Once it seems safe, consider these potential pluses:
- Ash raises soil pH to lower acidity. The raising of pH may or may not be beneficial, depending on how high the pH of garden soil already measures and the plants you are growing. Although most plants prefer only mildly acidic conditions, avoid applying ashes to the soil of acid-loving plants such as blueberries, hydrangeas, and potatoes.
- It adds micronutrients to the soil. In addition to calcium, ash for plants contains small amounts of other nutrients that can turn it into one of your secret ingredients for garden growth. Those nutrients include potassium, magnesium, phosphorus, sulfur, iron, manganese, zinc, and boron, among others.
- Ash aerates heavy soil to improve drainage. Among other wood ash uses is soil aeration. When worked into most soils, ashes add more air pockets, helping the soil to drain better. That may prevent problems caused by soggy conditions, such as root rot. Just use it in moderation, especially in soils already high in calcium, since repeated use of wood ash can lead to buildups of sodium and calcium.
- Wood ash makes soil more friable. Clay soil often can be hard to work in spring, due to its stickiness and tendency to clump when wet. Friable means “easily broken up.” Wood ash mixed in help soil crumble more readily, which means it is less compacted.
- It increases microbial nitrogen mineralization. Although most of the nitrogen in wood is released during the burning process, the breakdown of ashes in soil helps convert organic nitrogen already present there into the type that plants can use. However, you should never combine wood ash with nitrogen fertilizers, as that can produce ammonia gas.
- Sprinkled ash can repel slugs from plants. When sprinkled around plants, dry ashes reportedly irritate slugs and will prevent them from “crossing the line” to chow down on those plants. However, ashes cease being effective as a pest repellant once they become wet—and will have no effect on slugs already inside the line.
I’ve seen these benefits firsthand, especially with improving drainage in my clay-heavy backyard. Last year, I mixed in about a pound of ash per 100 square feet, and my tomato plants thrived with fewer root issues. The nutrient boost is real—wood ash can contain up to 20% calcium and 5% potassium, according to agricultural research, which is like a multivitamin for your soil. For slug control, I tried the ash trick around my hostas, and it worked like a charm until the first rain. If you’re dealing with heavy clay, a light application can make tilling so much easier, but don’t overdo it—too much calcium can lock up other nutrients, making them unavailable to plants.
Types of Wood Ash to Use (or Avoid) in the Garden
When considering what to do with wood ash, keep in mind that hardwood ashes, such as those from oaks and maples, contain more nutrients than those of softwood conifers such as pine and spruce. And ashes from young trees contain more nutrients than those from old trees. However, all types can be used in the garden, as well as the ashes of lump wood charcoal. Don’t include ashes of briquettes that might contain ingredients other than wood. Avoid applying ashes from painted or treated lumber or from trees that have grown near industrial sites and might contain contaminants. Although metals such as cadmium and lead aren’t easily taken up by plants, it’s best to be on the safe side. Also, make sure ashes applied to garden soil contain just wood ash and no plastics, oils, or coal ash, which will pollute the soil.
RELATED: The Best Soil Test Kits According to Our Tests
Choosing the right ash is key. I stick to hardwood ash from my fireplace, mostly oak, because it’s richer in nutrients—studies show hardwood ash can have 2-3 times more potassium than softwood. If you’re burning lump charcoal for a barbecue, that’s fine to use, but I learned the hard way to avoid briquettes after noticing some odd residue in my soil. For safety, I always check that my ash is pure wood with no additives. If you’re near industrial areas, get your ash tested for heavy metals; local labs can do this for about $30-$50. It’s a small price for peace of mind, especially if you’re growing edibles.
Composting Wood Ash
Although you can include ashes in compost, they should never make up more than 5 percent of the pile. The Royal Horticultural Society recommends that you “only add wood ash to the compost heap occasionally.” Only add once for every 6 inches of compost material; heavier use can raise the compost’s alkalinity and soluble salt levels, which could damage plants and soil. To check the level, the society says the ash should not be identifiable after it’s mixed into the compost. And, if you live in an area where the soil pH already is 7 or higher, you probably should avoid wood ash in compost—or in your garden—altogether.
Composting ash is tricky but doable. I sprinkle a thin layer of ash into my compost bin every few months, making sure it blends in completely. Last time, I overdid it and ended up with a batch that was too alkaline, which stunted my lettuce. The 5% rule is solid—think about a cup of ash for a 20-gallon compost bin. Research from composting studies suggests that small amounts of ash can boost microbial activity by 10-15%, but too much can throw off the balance. If your soil’s already neutral or alkaline, skip this step entirely to avoid trouble.
Direct Application
Don’t allow wood ash to become wet before you apply it, or else many of the nutrients will leach out prematurely. If you are substituting wood ashes for garden lime, use twice as much wood ash as the amount of lime recommended for your soil. However, don’t apply more than 15 to 20 pounds of ashes per 1,000 square feet of ground. Wear clothing that covers your arms and legs, goggles, and a dust mask when working with the ashes to prevent inhalation of particles or skin and eye irritation. Spread the ashes on a day when the soil is damp and no wind is blowing, preferably during fall, winter, or early spring. That allows the ashes time to break down before the garden begins to grow, since their salts may have an inhibiting effect on seed germination. Keep the ashes off the foliage of your plants and work them into the top 6 inches of ground.
I always apply ash in late fall—it’s less windy, and the soil’s usually damp enough to keep the dust down. Last year, I used about 10 pounds of ash for a 500-square-foot garden bed, raked it in, and saw great results with my beans by spring. The “double the lime” rule is handy; for example, if your soil test suggests 5 pounds of lime, use 10 pounds of ash instead. Safety-wise, I learned to wear a mask after getting a nasty cough from the dust. Agricultural extension services note that applying ash in early seasons gives it 3-6 months to integrate, reducing the risk of salt buildup that can harm young seedlings.
